Turing and the Integration of Human and Machine Intelligence

Philosophical discussion of Alan Turing’s writings on intelligence has mostly revolved around a single point made in a paper published in the journal Mind in 1950. This is unfortunate, for Turing’s reflections on machine (artificial) intelligence, human intelligence, and the relation between them were more extensive and sophisticated. They are seen to be extremely well-considered and sound in retrospect. Recently, IBM developed a question-answering computer (Watson) that could compete against humans on the game show Jeopardy! There are hopes it can be adapted to other contexts besides that game show, in the role of a collaborator of, rather than a competitor to, humans. Another, different, research project --an artificial intelligence program put into operation in 2010 --is the machine learning program NELL (Never Ending Language Learning), which continuously ‘learns’ by ‘reading’ massive amounts of material on millions of web pages. Both of these recent endeavors in artificial intelligence rely to some extent on the integration of human guidance and feedback at various points in the machine’s learning process. In this paper, I examine Turing’s remarks on the development of intelligence used in various kinds of search, in light of the experience gained to date on these projects. 1. Introduction: Isolation, Interference, and Immersion 2. Teaching Searching 3. Natural Searching 4. Being in a Search Party 5. Human Help & The Human Brake 6. NELL "Reading" the Web 7. IBM's Question-Answering Champion, Watson 8. Closing Thoughts 1 S. G. Sterrett, Curtis D. Gridley Distinguished Professor of the History and Philosophy of Science, Department of Philosophy, Wichita State University, Wichita, Kansas USA 67260 email: [email protected]